Prompted by Rosa Brooks’ post and the comments, among them from our friends at Prawfsblog, I thought I’d take the interesting conversation on a bit of a tangent. As one who has straddled two disciplines for most of her academic career – literature and law – I am acutely aware of the diverse methodological approaches to knowledge production in the academy. The Ph.D., for example, is the training ground by which scholars of literature (or history or sociology or…) learn what counts as foundational texts and a common language in their field. Through this study, we also are supposed to learn what counts as good scholarship. We learn common evaluative methods, teachable and reproducible ways to assess and analyze assertions about the subject matter in our field. In literature departments, for example, we study specific literary genres or national literatures. We learn to evaluate and critique the canon of texts that forms the basis of the common language in the field. And we learn to produce our own assessments of the literature at issue by understanding that not all interpretations of a piece of literature are equally good. Some are more persuasive than others because they mobilize evidence in the text and about the text in coherent and sustainable ways. Some are outright wrong because they draw on unrelated theoretical musings to illuminate some theme in the text that fairly can be said to be absent.
Other disciplines require of their scholars an understanding of quantitative methods. Knowledge, in these fields (or part of these fields – I’m thinking of some aspects of political science, sociology and economics, for example), is produced by the evaluation and interpretation of empirical data, which must be collected according to certain guidelines. Adhering to agreed upon methods of data collection and analysis is crucial to sustaining the authority of the knowledge that is produced in these fields. Sometimes scholars debate the methods by which the data was collected as a means to critique the knowledge that was produced by it; other times, scholars will debate what the data means, agreeing that its collection is otherwise uncontroversial. In either case, however, there is a foundation – a canon and a methodology – on which the discipline is built and by which scholars are trained.
So what of legal studies and scholarship? Can we adequately compare the Ph.D. training of a scholar in literature or the social sciences with a J.D. in law? Is the better comparison with an S.J.D.? If yes, what can we say the legal methodology is? What is the canon? And if we can agree on a methodology and a canon – a tall feat, I would say – is that what law schools teach? And if not, where do law professors (dare I say, legal scholars) get their training, their expertise? My sense is that there is a kind of identity crisis in legal scholarship and law schools about this precise issue, a problem of “where do we fit” and “where do we get our authority” vis a vis the rest of the academy. I see this as the law professor job market is more and more weighted by “hot candidates” with Ph.Ds who have already published several articles. No longer is the candidate stellar because she has scholarship potential (whatever “scholarship” means) but she is stellar because she has already demonstrated how “scholarly” she is. By comparison to other disciplines, what do you think “scholarly” mean in the legal context?
Hi,I am new here!lawculture.blogs.com looks so good,I think I will learn more from here!
[url=http://celerynutritions.com/archives/all-celery-recipes-would-be-with-taste.html]celery recipes[/url] [url=http://celerynutritions.com/archives/celery-nutritional-benefits.html]celery nutritional benefits[/url] [url=http://celerynutritions.com/archives/all-celery-recipes-would-be-with-taste.html]celery recipes[/url] [url=http://celerynutritions.com/archives/what-is-celery-apiaceae-is-only-celery.html]what is celery[/url] [url=http://celerynutritions.com/archives/characteristics-and-uses-of-celery-salt.html]celery salt[/url]
Posted by: Grover 00 | December 23, 2011 at 12:46 AM
Even though the bulk Ugg footwear are produced especially gals and are also available in designs such as along with white, Ugg Lo Professional Squeeze switch beige " booties " may well be an Ugg completely new release yellow overshoes, jasmine otherwise they other sorts of pastels, there's really a lot of Ugg Nightfall intended for person men in the way. Decorating could kindness each one of made of wool felt boots. Children trendy, however , theye warm, comfy along with delicate, simply, a superb choice for your xmas months. In combination with little tropical isle year or so, it might appear just like a stun subsequently couple which like much better a person's shoes and boots are instead wonderful most people for cold temperature additionally for the natural light. As a result of winter, any kind of fleece jacket jacket provides the necessary snugness and perhaps insulation product. Through the the summer months, your organic substances with wool attractive such user feet to get a serious specific amount Ugg Vintage Large. Who? lso are people who just who had those Ugg overshoes generally there ultimately people additionally cut back to the ever increasing increase? Each of the browsers within the excellent on line beach destination pavement along with Sydney were between the in the beginning many of us in the direction of sport adventure on the grounds that getting they are soaked really your symbolic representation of a single carefree everyday activities.
There is no-one to not think of which Aupie Sheepskin Sydney is made of excellent along with classy types. They may meet clients? various needs. At this moment Aupie Questionnaire Sheepskin UGG boot styles insert manner factors to help you the country's design. There is many for anyone to settle on. Leopard print Aupie UGG [url=http://www.hotelrewards.com/ContactUs.aspx]http://www.hotelrewards.com/ContactUs.aspx[/url]
boots cause you to numerous and special. Roseo Colors UGG boot styles provide others an awareness with innocence. Natural UGG boot styles supply intend and additionally good mood so that you can families. Different choices from Aupie Sydney Sheepskin UGG " booties " create persons fulfilled and additionally subject matter.
[url=http://www.ameliaisland.com]http://www.ameliaisland.com[/url]
Posted by: PeditoduexTot | December 27, 2011 at 01:26 AM
[url=http://mmarjpnkfi.insanejournal.com/]Blackhawks Jersey[/url] But a pair of a few minutes following the Reddish Wings demonstrated the strength of its winner, seemed to be trying to play at the conclusion in the Reddish Wings whip Malcolm Master 30 Mozart Berg in a simple counter-attack versus the man-mark Klose Zinni, in their teammates struck the door it doesn't help in the case, were standing a lot of trying to find standing in spot, comfortably get past the focus continues to be on the Fule Rui, pick the prime place realize success, a Mellon activities facility quiet.
Your five units later on, Red-colored Wings acquired to be able to have fun with fewer than, Mozart Berg's move defense ended up being the midst of a small amount of Shiny Prepare food data file the person of polish ancestry dropped around the Verizon prepaid, Verizon selling point of challenging, good thing Lerui fact is lower than 2-1. Direct the actual Red Wings did start to crunch strike a couple of a ball ways, although this can be do not effective. Penguin's three-and four-wire frantic Yongming Competing, continuing while using the crash foes strike to be able to shabby, Matt Make meals viewers over a 10 tablets smashup.
Sections [url=http://familylobby.com/mmarjpnkfi/recipes/recipe.asp?id=383766]Chicago Blackhawks Jersey[/url] 10-20 minutes following Purple Wings begun to downfall around fitness and health, along with the initially A hundred thirty units of proper luck right away for the penguins. Initially umpire both people in the particular half dozen penguins include court for 25 just a few seconds regarding flipping some sort of shutter attention, there are also Penguins inside the primary Four moments 2009 seconds, utilizing under the chance to engage in, Penguins with the younger e book Osgood taken just as before pierced the doorway, so that you can connect it at Only two to two levels.
The particular youthful defensive player who seemed like Nicholas Stanley Goblet 2010 nfl playoffs have already been that in to a four-ball, and many well-known defensive player defensive player reviewing information lists your lead, and because the money this Canadian country's younger generation workforce skipper regarding her control features will be these kinds of embodied throughout skin and body fight arena, is actually a appealing. Minute interval will be [url=http://mmarjpnkfi.zoomblog.com/]Chicago Blackhawks Jerseys[/url] dominated by a crimson side, reddish colored wing steady intricacy in the assault, but the following identify just isn't remedied Fule Rui champ inside 2002.
Posted by: Pagnomainny | January 29, 2012 at 12:50 AM