The Value of Torture

       In teaching constitutional law, a theme I develop throughout the course is whether there are anchors for our interpretation of the constitution's text, whether there are stable values or ideals that guide our application of the constitution to the new facts presented such that we can both evolve over time as well as recognize in the interpretation a societal identity, a continuity of community that was founded on these central principles in 1776 and 1789. 

       In Justice Holmes' famous dissent in Lochner, he wrote that the constitution is made for "people of fundamentally differing views," speaking, of course, of various theories of economics and social justice debated between the majority and dissents in that case.  But Holmes' comment begs the question that I find myself asking over and over this past day as I contemplate how the U.S. House of Representatives could have passed the so-called "torture bill" by a majority of 253 to 168.  Although sufficiently capacious to maintain differing views of "equality," "free speech," and "commerce" can we really say that the constitution makes room for the purposefully threatening, degrading, humiliating and violent treatment of prisoners of war? (As Marty Lederman writes here, the treatment may apply to more than prisoners of war, but to any "enemy combatant" so designated by the Commander in Chief.)

       On September 11, 2001, I felt vengeful. I felt violent. I recognized in me a common human reaction to hate-motivated violence: a like response of hate-motivated violence.  I wanted the terrorists who killed the September 11 victims and the terrorists' loved ones to die.  But as much as this might be a common human response, it seems to me obvious it is not the right response. It is not the good response. It is not the moral response. It does not promote peace or justice. It repeats and continues hatred and violence.

       And so why would we, as a society founded on liberty, opportunity, fairness, a society that has grown into the value of equality -- all of which are manifested in the constitution -- why would we condone the tactics proposed by the torture bill? (In addition to being so vague on what constitutes prohibited torture, the bill also removes the right to petition for liberty -- the right to file a writ of habeas corpus -- for anyone so detained. Can you imagine being held against your will indefinitely with no way to contest your detention because someone in the executive department has labeled you an enemy combatant? If that isn't tyranny, I am not sure what is. Cf. US Const. Art. 1, Sec. 9, cl. 2 (“The privilege of the writ of habeas corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in cases of rebellion or invasion the public safety may require it”) and Ex parte Milligan, 71 US 2 (1866) (only the privilege, not the writ itself, is suspended, such that a court can pass on the constitutionality of the suspension).  Due process of law, prohibitions on cruel and unusual punishment, these terms might be vague, but certainly they prohibit waterboarding and sleep deprivation.  (Were police ever to use such tactics against criminal suspects there would be no question of a constitutional violation.)  There are lots of good arguments as to why these kinds of tactics are futile and bad policy -- they produce unreliable information and excludable evidence, they model a behavior we have criticized other countries for employing.  But isn't the best reason for saying "no" to the torture bill that our society's values as embodied in our constitution require we treat even the most vile of human beings as human beings? Except for losing control over our impulses and letting our hatred and fear get the better of us, why would we destroy the reputation and identity of the United States that is embodied, hopefully, in the promise that is our constitution, by condoning the violence that is being done to these prisoners?

Comments

[Sam9969]

What is missing in this post is the violence and corruption that is done to the torturers. With the signing into law of this act the honor of the United States will be lost. The MCA represents our capitualtion in the war of civilations. Was this the responce that Osama was looking for?

[JSilbey]

Sam9969, you are absolutely right. I gather by justifying violence as the US Congress has done this week, it will be harder to distinguish US military tactics from terrorist tactics.

[buy propecia]

this post is very interesting about The Value of Torture thanks for sharing!!

[Tom Li]

These affordable and [url=http://www.rpgshow.com /]full lace wigs[/url] and [url=http://www.rpgshow.com /]lace wigs[/url] are the evidence and adage that luxury and quality styling accessories are not just made for the rich. Thus, any women can improve their [url=http://www.rpgshow.com /]lace front wigs[/url] and [url=http://www.rpgshow.com/lace-front-wigs-c-12.html /]lace front wigs[/url] and looking like or even better than celebrities. It serves the different hair styles and beauty for you. You can use these cheap lace wigs than the expensive ones and it never fails.

[coach handbags]

Go for someone who makes you smile because it takes only a smile to make a dark day seem bright.

[Coach Outlet]

Chief Justice Robert's decision for the unanimous Court in in the law school/military recruiting

[Poppy]

rapidshare search http://mediafiretorrent.com mediafire torrent

[lace wigs]

I wanted the terrorists who killed the September 11 victims and the terrorists' loved ones to die. But as much as this might be a common human response, it seems to me obvious it is not the right response. lace wigs

[Impotence causes]

Good evening to all readers, my name is Roy, two years ago I received a special treatment for cancer and work out, I like to share this experience mainly to emphasize the importance of treatment in all the different diseases.

thanks!!!

[Cheap viagra]

For me it is a pleasure to comment on a blog like this, to me personally I liked very much reading, I agree with everything they say the above comments, I think if every day items like these appear in the network, I would sit at my computer reading these articles.

[jordan 2]

Thanks for the sharing of those photos and painting works! I wonder whether you are thinking about posting a manual of HDRI? That will be helpful.

[Air Jordan Shoes]

Other people think of not only their own welfare but also the welfare of others.

[cheap nike shox]

You are eternal beings, you are God force.You are our god!

[Mike Rothrock]

I couldn't agree with you more. Terrorists do not fight in large part over land or resources as is the case with most wars. It's an ideological attack. If in response to terrorism we adapt some of the same ideals and values as the terrorist regimes we find repulsive, are we not letting them win and brining ourselves down to their level? Is that what we truly want in our society? Two wrongs do not make a right. It seems to me that the legislatures, many of whom are also lawyers, should be find a solution to the problem by going back to Law School 101: To get the right answer, you have to first ask the right question.

[Robert]

I think someone being tortured will say anything even if it's not true just to stop the torturer.

[Winding Up Petition]

If you have been issued with a winding up petition for your company because the company owes money. You can pay the money owed before the court date and get the case droped or fight it if you believe it to be worth defending.

[tanik]

Recent articles. I think this is the most beautiful in the world the article, there must be many people like it your works will get everyone recognized you is the best I will always support you.

[Account Deleted]

Moe Nawaz is recognised as the UK's Most Trusted Insolvency Auditors and mastermind business coach. He has worked in the turnaround industry since 1989. Moe helps over 500 business people every year via a free advice line ukadvice.com. Moe is the founder of mastermind business coaching and a mastermind executive coach himself. His clients include high tech companies, manufacturers, financial services, entrepreneurs and family run businesses throughout Europe. He has been featured on TV, Radio and other Media.

[Soma without prescription]

fwisgmbxdvmuvsf, Buy injectable ativan, NPAysOl, [url=http://www.therative.com/in-the-news.html]Ativan lorazepam buy cheap ativan online[/url], DxXGLeg, http://www.therative.com/in-the-news.html Ativan lorazepam buy cheap ativan online, iyDCvoY, Buy xanax without prescription in usa, boxWGaC, [url=http://www.southofthebroad.com/xanax.html]Can i buy xanax in mexico without a prescription[/url], XRwkhDa, http://www.southofthebroad.com/xanax.html Buy xanax online overnight delivery, mbPfHrl, Soma, lnFpQRu, [url=http://www.bestmusclerelaxer.net/]Where to order soma[/url], wyZYUmr, http://www.bestmusclerelaxer.net/ Hotels in soma san francisco, tAOmelI, Buy xanax in blister packs, MlRVfxG, [url=http://therative.com/products.html]Buy xanax and diazapam[/url], UzgMsok, http://therative.com/products.html Buy xanax online in the usa, IAykStt, Buy Ativan, chhGURr, [url=http://www.createsuccess101.com/ativan.html]Buy injectable ativan[/url], vsJULWK, http://www.createsuccess101.com/ativan.html Buy online c.o.d ativan 2 mg 500 cents a piece, bDpZcgX, Valium, LkSPGqm, [url=http://www.anxietysos.net/]Bibliophile valium comments e-mail name comment [b][/b] - [i][/i] - [u][/u]- [quote][/[/url], KgPrQBv, http://www.anxietysos.net/ Valium effects, gGJtOqQ.

[Order valium medication]

cktdjmbxdvmuvsf, Buy valium online no prescription medication, YvaAOkX, [url=http://fdshred.com/about_florida_document_shredding_orlando.html]Order valium medication[/url], laqTqPC, http://fdshred.com/about_florida_document_shredding_orlando.html Buy valium no rx money worldwide delivery, lUQOCkh.

[Animal porn]

chedvmbxdvmuvsf, Free teen porn, HLQhydU, [url=http://pornfaq.net/]Hamster porn[/url], pVPgoop, http://pornfaq.net/ Black porn, wvQuXJh.

[Clonazepam half life]

kwvammbxdvmuvsf, Clonazepam tev, MbqPjIx, [url=http://cokercreekgallery.com/new/pages/contact.htm]Clonazepam manufactured by activas[/url], KisaNvD, http://cokercreekgallery.com/new/pages/contact.htm Quick sober up on clonazepam, uYghDNP.

[Clonazepam half life]

kwvammbxdvmuvsf, Clonazepam tev, MbqPjIx, [url=http://cokercreekgallery.com/new/pages/contact.htm]Clonazepam manufactured by activas[/url], KisaNvD, http://cokercreekgallery.com/new/pages/contact.htm Quick sober up on clonazepam, uYghDNP.

[Generic Propecia]

glzalmbxdvmuvsf, Propecia, TAlstJC, [url=http://www.adamandcheri.com/rsvp.html]Generic Propecia[/url], JiKpNfc, http://www.adamandcheri.com/rsvp.html Propecia, qsRibDt.

[treatment for eye floaters]

zxznymbxdvmuvsf, floaters in your eye, sMswrmw, [url=http://besteyefloaterstreatment.com/]eye floaters removal[/url], euZexsD, http://besteyefloaterstreatment.com/ floaters in eye, tiXAUJb, spyglass, ZEnoIxr, [url=http://seosoftwaresnow.com/]spyglass app[/url], HhppTNX, http://seosoftwaresnow.com/ seo spyglass review, UoSJuLB, Finasteride, fEnofuM, [url=http://www.flannerys.net/about.html]Finasteride effectiveness[/url], UeomLeS, http://www.flannerys.net/about.html Minoxidil finasteride hormone, SdzspMx, seo powersuite reviews, BDJdEmn, [url=http://seosoftwarenow.com/]seo powersuite download[/url], viRyKnd, http://seosoftwarenow.com/ seo powersuite discount, EUwaCaa, Indian vegetarian recipes, KJUOXXe, [url=http://recipesquestions.com/]Baking recipes[/url], eLGsycN, http://recipesquestions.com/ Recipes of making crank meth, QiYleSc, Divx codec windows media center, wVfWjoY, [url=http://divxcodec-advice.org/]Xubuntu codec divx[/url], XRbzonr, http://divxcodec-advice.org/ Divx plus codec, uDkliCN.